The Great DRAGONLANCE Re-Read – Dragons of Spring Dawning, by Margaret Weis and Tracy Hickman

First Impression: The end of Chronicles is here at last! This is the shortest review so far – most of what I’ve said so far is true for this book as well. Once again, I showed Claire the cover art and asked her what she thought about it. Here’s her thoughts:

  • Original Larry Elmore cover: This is one of the most 80s things I have ever seen. Happy to see that green dragon is looking a little more threatening than its photobombing predecessors
  • Reprint Larry Elmore cover: I don’t 100% know why, maybe it’s the green and red contrasts in these last two covers, but I am liking these covers a lot. The dragon looks way too friendly and calm though. And geez that armour is camp. They don’t make ’em like that anymore.
  • UK cover by Keith Parkinson: So I am becoming familiar with the pattern of Dragonlance covers through the ages, and I get the feeling like this event depicted doesn’t even happen in this book? I quite like it in terms of an action image, although I also get the feeling that it is weirdly positioned/cropped. It’s nice to actually feel the threat from the dragon for once, and to see a character in an action pose rather than posing for the camera (James: She’s right – it’s the climax of Dragons of Winter Night; terribly cropped, once again. Why are the UK covers so bad?!)
  • Matt Stawicki cover: Okay I actually really like this one, I think it’s the mistiness of the background and the detail of the architecture behind the characters. On the negative side, I find the poses really awkward. But their clothing looks way more appealing to my modern sensibilities compared to the 80s stuff

Plot Summary: Tanis Half-Elven sneaks out on his girlfriend Kitiara, the Dragon HIghlord in the middle of the night and he and his companions try to escape. Kitiara chases after him on a dragon, but the ship is sucked into a whirlpool made of blood! Raistlin betrays the party and magics himself away just before the ship goes underwater. Fortunately, passing sea elves rescue the drowning adventurers and put them ashore along with the ship’s helmsman, Berem – an immortal MacGuffin who can win or lose the war. Meanwhile, Tanis’ other girlfriend, the elf princess Laurana, becomes the Golden General, in charge of the armies of Good. With the help of the good dragons, who have finally returned, and wielding the dragonlances, Laurana is able to win a series of major victories. However, she abandons her armies when Kitiara lies and tells her Tanis is hurt, and is captured in a very obvious trap. Our scattered heroes finally reunite and go to Neraka, the HQ of the Dragonarmies, to rescue Laurana and use Berem to win the war. Caramon, Tika, and Tasslehoff have to complete a final dungeon crawl with Berem to stop the dark goddess Takhisis, while Tanis has to choose which girlfriend he likes more. Suddenly, Raistlin returns – but now he’s Super-Saiyan Raistlin (except his robes turned black instead of his hair going golden) Thanks to this Raistlin-ex-machina, the heroes are victorious – but Kitiara takes control of the remaining Dragonarmies, and Raistlin is now free to pursue his own nefarious plans…

The Good: Once again, the characters continue to be the best part of this series. Weis and Hickman make an extremely sensible decision to not make the climax be the defeat of the Queen of Darkness – her brief appearance is impressive, but she’s too abstract a character to be an effective primary antagonist. Instead, the climax of the novel is the resolution of Tanis’ internal conflict, and the confrontation between the brothers Caramon and Raistlin. 

I’d forgotten how long it took him to appear, but the most legendarily badass character in Dragonlance finally appeared halfway through this book: Lord Soth, the undead Knight of the Black Rose! He has virtually nothing to do here, but he makes such an impression. I remembered him being more style than substance, but that’s not a problem here, and he’s got so much style!

My favourite character, to my surprise, wound up being Tasslehoff! I think it’s because I now have a toddler, but I appreciate his empathy, his innocence and his curiosity. His character development to become wiser, sadder, and more mature – in other words, his loss of innocence – happens slowly and organically.

The Neutral: This book is set in 352 A.C. It covers material from the eighth, tenth, and especially the climactic twelfth adventures. The eighth adventure, in which Gilthanas and Silvara infiltrate the enemy stronghold of Sanction to discover the secret origin of the draconians and recruit the good dragons to their side, is summarized by them in a single chapter after they return: the story is told more fully in Lords of Doom, a pick-a-path book. Meanwhile, the story of Raistlin’s rise to near omnipotence would not be covered until Dragons of the Hourglass Mage, published twenty-four years later!

The Bad: I got the feeling, reading this, that Weis and Hickman had lost interest in this book even before they started writing it. Their hearts were clearly set on telling their own original story about the wizard Raistlin, and so this book serves more as a bridge to set up the following Legends trilogy than a grand finale to this story. Characters are dropped along the wayside so that the story can focus on those who will be important next time: Raistlin, Caramon, Tasslehoff, and Kitiara. As a result, major revelations like the origins of the draconians are hurried, while the mystery of what’s been going on with Raistlin is deferred to be covered in Legends. 

Other major plot points are nonsensical. Laurana’s decision to go running after Tanis is particularly egregious. I was reading the Annotated Chronicles, in which both Weis and Hickman agree that Laurana’s decision is forced and out of character. Berem’s backstory, which is vital for the resolution of the war, also doesn’t really hold up to scrutiny. The only thing stopping Takhisis the dragon goddess from conquering the world is getting the gem out of his chest – that she put there herself?

Final Impressions: Three Disks of Mishakal out of five. Weis and Hickman have done an admirable job wrestling twelve D&D adventures into three novels. By modern standards, the Chronicles trilogy doesn’t really hold up. I couldn’t in good faith recommend it compared to some of the amazing fantasy novels out there today. But back in the Eighties, when there was less variety on the shelves, this was excellent. Like all classics, it’s of its time and place. I really enjoyed revisiting Chronicles, and I’m looking forward to the Legends trilogy, which I remember being the high water mark for the Dragonlance saga.

But before I start Legends, there was another series of books that came between them: the Super Endless Quest pick-a-path gamebooks were the very first spinoff Dragonlance books, so I’ll be looking at them next fortnight.

One thought on “The Great DRAGONLANCE Re-Read – Dragons of Spring Dawning, by Margaret Weis and Tracy Hickman

  1. Brendan Guy says:

    Afraid I have to disagree with your take on Laurana in this book as well. (And I hope you don’t mind a long post because I have a lot to say regarding the Trap plotline.)

    First, I disagree that Laurana fell for a “very obvious trap” as she actually had good reason to think that Kitiara was a honorable enemy who could be trusted to respect a truce given her own prior dealings with Kitiara at the High Clerist’s Tower where Kitiara had behaved in a honorable manner and had not attacked her even when catching her in an extremely vulnerable position. (Logically if Kitiara had wanted to kill or capture her then Kitiara would have done so at the High Clerist’s Tower, so the fact that Kitiara did not attack her there is strong evidence that Kitiara genuinely does not want to harm her.) Likewise the fact that Tanis loved Kitiara would also give Laurana good reason to think Kitiara could be trusted since Laurana (not unreasonably) believed Tanis to be a good and wise person, and you would not expect a good and wise person to fall in love with someone that was truly dishonorable. And of course these two considerations would support each other as Kitiara’s honorable behavior at the High Clerist’s Tower would seemingly confirm Laurana’s belief that Tanis wouldn’t love Kitiara if she wasn’t honorable.)

    Nor is the idea of a military commander in ancient or medieval warfare meeting with the enemy in person (and with few or no body guards) at all ridiculous. We see It happen in ancient literature (think King Priam going in person behind Greek line to bargain for his son’s body at the end of The Iliad) and more importantly there are also numerous historical examples of this practice as well. Saladin met with an emissary from the Assassins with only two bodyguards present, Hannibal Barca and Scipio Africanus met in person right before the Battle of Zama with each only having a single body guard present, and Harold Godwinson rode up to parley with the invading Norwegians with no body guards with him at all. Those men were all capable generals (indeed Hannibal and Scipio are considered two of the greatest generals in military history), so Laurana’s in good company as a general who agreed to meet in person with the enemy.

    Nor was it unreasonable for Laurana to want to go to Tanis when she thought he was dying. Even aside from her love for Tanis (and wanting to see a loved one before they die is hardly an absurd desire), Tanis was also the man who had saved her life in Tarsis and led the mission that saved her people from genocide, and as such it would be understandable that Laurana felt she had a duty to try and comfort Tanis when he was dying, and since her army was in a good position (fully supplied and manned in a fortified city with no significant enemy forces nearby), it was also understandable that she felt that in that moment Tanis needed her more than her army did. And of course if Kitiara had been telling the truth (which as discussed above Laurana had good reason to believe she was doing) then the disruption to Laurana’s army would have been minimal. (Indeed most likely Laurana would have made the exchange and returned before anyone even knew she was gone.)

    And as for the idea that a capable military commander would never do something like this, it’s worth noting that in World War 2, General George Patton authorized a foolhardy rescue mission for his captured son-in-law (Task Force Baum), which just shows that even the strongest, most capable of generals can still be emotionally compromised when their loved ones are suffering. Thus despite what Weis and Hickman said, I thought Laurana’s decision was both realistic and understandable.

    And regardless of the merits of this plotline at least it set up Laurana’s subsequent heroics in the Neraka chapters which is some of the most epic heroism in the entire saga.

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s